A comparative study of reproductive performance in organic and conventional dairy husbandry

Abstract

A comparative cohort study of reproductive performance in organic and conventional dairy husbandry was conducted using longitudinal data from the Norwegian National Board of Animal Production Recording from January 1, 1994 to December 31, 1996. The present study is the first study comparing reproductive efficiency in organic and conventional husbandry in which characteristics such as herd size, breeding season, milk yield, parity, breed, use of artificial insemination (AI), and geographical distribution were taken into account. The organically managed cohort comprised 998 lactation periods, and the conventionally managed cohort comprised 3016 lactation periods. Both groups were similar in herd size and geographical distribution. The following reproduction variables were studied: days open, calving interval, calving to first AI interval, calving to last AI interval, and AI per cow. No consistent difference in reproductive performance was found between the cohorts before adjustments were made for milk yield, breeding season, service, and parity. After inclusion of these independent variables in the repeated measures, mixed-model analyses, reproductive efficiency of organically managed dairy cows was impaired compared with those under conventional management. In organic dairy farming, breeding efficiency was difficult to maintain in cows bred during winter. Organic husbandry proved more efficient than did conventional husbandry in converting roughage into milk. Furthermore, the average multiparity percentage was higher in organically managed cows.