Definitional Dilemmas

Abstract

The introduction of identity theft into contemporary society caused considerable conceptual confusion. The mere terminology became the source of vivid discus- sions, especially since individuals with a legal background questioned the usage of the word ‘theft’ in association with identity. The main question from the legal front became: can someone steal an identity? Traditional definitions of theft in criminal law conflicted with the meaning of the term as used in the concept of identity theft. Certain sources therefore labelled identity theft a misnomer1 or referred to the concept as ‘awkward.’2 Some even demonstrate a complete disdain for the term.3 Others, on the other hand, embrace the concept and its accuracy.