Domesticated Nature: The Culturally Constructed Niche of Humanity

Abstract

William Denevan argued that pristine landscapes are a myth, including in Amazonia-imagined by many as one of the last bastions of pristine Nature. During the last century, evidence accumulated to show that humans domesticated Nature during the Holocene by creating cultural niches in all habitable regions of the planet. This process of cultural niche construction is the result of human agency, grounded on culturally transmitted ecological knowledge to domesticate landscapes, and plant and animal populations, thus increasing human carrying capacity. The expansion of culturally constructed niches during the Holocene does not mean that every inch of the habitable planet became a garden; rather, there is a mosaic of landscapes domesticated to different degrees, especially forests. Consequently, domesticated landscapes depend upon their humans, even though humans can also degrade these landscapes, which gave rise to the Anthropocene concept. As a result, Edward O. Wilson proposed that half of the biosphere be set aside for Nature. Many prime areas for the half-Earth proposal are tropical forests, all with high linguistic diversity; Borneo, New Guinea, the Congo, and Amazonia are examples. Since all of Nature in the habitable regions of the planet is cultural to some degree, setting aside half requires partnership with local human populations, rather than their exclusion, which is too common today. Their participation is essential, because it is their niche construction activities that resulted in what we call Nature and without them Nature will change-through natural processes-into something different from that which we plan to conserve.