Debora: Long-Term Effectiveness of an Inpatient Combined Pain Competence and Depression Prevention Training for Non-Specific Chronic Low Back Pain and Depressive Symptoms

Abstract

Objective To investigate the effects of an intervention for pain competence and depression prevention for multidisciplinary inpatient rehabilitation of non-specific chronic low back pain on psychological and work-related outcomes over a 2-year period. Methods This prospective randomized controlled multicenter trial evaluated the effects of pain competence training with and without depression prevention on depressive symptoms (General Depression Scale; ADS; primary outcome), anxiety (Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale), pain self-efficacy (Pain Self-Efficacy Questionnaire) and subjective prognosis of gainful employment (SPE; secondary outcomes) in n=422 patients aged 32-64 years from four rehabilitation clinics. Per protocol analyses were conducted. In the three-factorial design with a repeated-measures factor, patients were stratified by treatment condition; the control group (CG) received only pain management training but the intervention group (IG) was additionally treated with depression prevention training (Debora). Based on the ADS, patients were assigned to without or low depressive symptoms (ADS<23; n=208) and medium or high depressive symptoms (ADS≥23; n=214). The fivefold repeated-measures factor included the following sample points: admission, immediately after and 6, 12, and 24 months after rehabilitation. Per protocol results of univariate 2×2×5 analyses of variance were validated by n=1225 multiple imputed data. Results No significant effects of treatment condition over the 2-year period were yielded in the primary outcome depressive symptoms, but only patients with the combined training Debora benefited in pain self-efficacy in the long term. Intention-to-treat analyses suggest incremental effects of Debora on pain self-efficacy and anxiety at 24-month follow-up. In the long term, patients with high levels of depressive symptoms improved exclusively in depressive symptoms or they benefited more than patients with low depression in anxiety. However, favorable effects receded in general from post rehabilitation to 24-month follow-up. Discussion The results support that a disorder-specific depression prevention training is needed for the long-term improvement in pain self-efficacy, which is considered a crucial psychological protective factor in pain chronification. Findings on depressive symptoms support the effectiveness of multidisciplinary inpatient rehabilitation in high depression, but also the great importance of early treatment of depressive symptoms. Conclusion Overall, the results strengthen the need to implement psychotherapeutic treatment elements and, in particular, cognitive-behavioral methods and, moreover, a systematic allocation of patients to needs-based treatments in order to improve long-term effects.