Plastid DNA sequence data help to clarify phylogenetic relationships and reticulate evolution in Lycoris (Amaryllidaceae)

Abstract

The temperate East Asian genus Lycoris is a well known lineage of ornamental geophytes consisting of at least 20 species, some of which are thought to be of natural hybrid origin. Previous genetic studies have supported this hypothesis, but these have relied solely on the use of karyology and/or nuclear ribosomal ITS sequences. No plastid DNA data have been available to address interspecific relationships within Lycoris until now. In this study, 500 individuals from 29 populations representing 16 of the 20 published Lycoris spp. were sampled, and DNA sequences were generated for two plastid markers (trnS-trnfM and trnC-ycf6). From these data we inferred phylogenetic relationships among the sampled taxa at the species and population levels using concatenated phylogenetic methods. A well resolved and strongly supported phylogenetic reconstruction for Lycoris was obtained. Although the plastid DNA topology differs from that derived previously using ITS, both genomes produce trees that cluster Lycoris spp. into three clades. One of these, containing polyploid taxa such as L.albiflora, L.caldwellii, L.straminea and L.houdyshelii, shows strong evidence of reticulation, and we discuss the identity of potential parents of these allopolyploids. In contrast, we offer evidence that challenges the hypothesis that triploid individuals of L.radiata are the result of hybridization. Instead, they appear to be autotriploids that have arisen in more than one location. By comparing the phylogenetic results obtained using nuclear genomic data to those from the plastid genome, a much clearer picture of the role that hybridization and reticulation have played in the evolution of Lycoris is emerging.