No general soil carbon sequestration under Central European short rotation coppices

Abstract

Wood from short rotation coppices (SRCs) is discussed as bioenergy feedstock with good climate mitigation potential inter alia because soil organic carbon (SOC) might be sequestered by a land-use change (LUC) from cropland to SRC. To test if SOC is generally enhanced by SRC over the long term, we selected the oldest Central European SRC plantations for this study. Following the paired plot approach soils of the 21 SRCs were sampled to 80 cm depth and SOC stocks, C/N ratios, pH and bulk densities were compared to those of adjacent croplands or grasslands. There was no general trend to SOC stock change by SRC establishment on cropland or grassland, but differences were very site specific. The depth distribution of SOC did change. Compared to cropland soils, the SOC density in 0-10 cm was significantly higher under SRC (17 ± 2 in cropland and 21 ± 2 kg C m-3 in SRC). Under SRC established on grassland SOC density in 0-10 cm was significantly lower than under grassland. The change rates of total SOC stocks by LUC from cropland to SRC ranged from -1.3 to 1.4 Mg C ha-1 yr-1 and -0.6 Mg C ha-1 yr-1 to +0.1 Mg C ha-1 yr-1 for LUC from grassland to SRC, respectively. The accumulation of organic carbon in the litter layer was low (0.14 ± 0.08 Mg C ha-1 yr-1). SOC stocks of both cropland and SRC soils were correlated with the clay content. No correlation could be detected between SOC stock change and soil texture or other abiotic factors. In summary, we found no evidence of any general SOC stock change when cropland is converted to SRC and the identification of the factors determining whether carbon may be sequestered under SRC remains a major challenge.