Adherence to integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) guidelines by community health workers in Kano State, Nigeria through use of a clinical decision support (CDS) platform

Abstract

Background: The World Health Organization (WHO) Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI) guidelines established in 1992 to decrease preventable under-five child morbidity and mortality, was adopted by Nigeria in 1997. Over 20 years later, while under-five child mortality remains high, less than 25% of first level facilities have trained 60% of community health workers (CHW) who care for sick children with IMCI. This study investigated the impact in CHWs overall adherence to IMCI guidelines, particularly for critical danger signs, as well as usability and feasible following the implementation of THINKMD’s IMCI-based digital clinical decision support (CDS) platform. Methods: Adherence to IMCI guidelines was assessed by observational and digital data acquisition of key IMCI clinical data points by 28 CHWs, prior, during, and post CDS platform implementation. Change in IMCI adherence was determined for individual CHW and for the cohort by analyzing the number of IMCI data points acquired by each CHW per clinical evaluation. Consistency of adherence was also calculated by averaging the percentage of total evaluations each data point was observed. Usability and acceptability surveys were administered following use of the CDS platform. Results: THINKMD CDS platform implementation notably enhanced the CHWs’ ability to capture key IMCI clinical data elements. We observed a significant increase in the mean percentage of data points captured between the baseline period and during the CDS technology implementation (T-test, t = -31.399, p < 0.016, Holm-Bonferroni correction, two-sided), with the mean values going from 30.7% to 72.4%. Notably, even after the completion of the technology implementation phase, the mean percentage of IMCI elements captured by CHWs remained significantly elevated compared to the baseline, with a 26.72 percentage point increase (from 30.7% to 57.4%, T-test, t = -15.779, p < 0.05, Holm-Bonferroni correction, two-sided). Usability and feasibility of the platform was high. CHWs reported that the CDS platform was easy to learn and use (93%) and enabled them to identify sick children (100%). Conclusion: These results demonstrate that utilization of a digital clinical decision support tool such as THINKMD’s IMCI based CDS platform can significantly increase CHW adherence to IMCI guidelines over paper-based utilization, increase clinical quality and capacity, and improve identification of key danger signs for under-five children while being highly accepted and adopted.