Comparison of field- and laboratory-based estimates of muscle quality index between octogenarians and young older adults: an observational study

Abstract

Muscle quality (the ratio of strength to lean muscle mass) might be a better indicator of muscle function than strength alone. Differences in muscle quality index (MQI) between octogenarians and young older adults remain unclear. The aims of the present cross-sectional study were to compare (1) MQI between octogenarians and young older adults, (2) lab versus field-based MQI tools, and (3) determine possible confounding factors affecting MQI in older adults. Compiled data from two cross-sectional studies included 175 younger and older adults (31 men and 144 women) with a mean age of 75.93 ± 9.49 years. Participants with age ≥ 80 years old were defined as octogenarians (n = 79) and < 80 years was defined as young older adults (n = 96). Laboratory MQI was derived from the ratio of grip strength to arm muscle mass (in kg) mea- sured by dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry. Field-based MQI was quantified from the ratio of grip strength to body mass index (BMI). Octogenarians displayed lower field (P = 0.003) and laboratory MQI (P<0.001) as compared with young older adults. There was a strong correlation effect between field MQI and laboratory MQI (P=0.001, R= 0.85). BMI (P=0.001), and diabetes mellitus (P= 0.001) negatively affected MQI. Women presented lower MQI (P= 0.001) values than men. In light of this information, rehabilitation specialists should consider the use of field-based MQI as a tool for evaluation and follow-up of older population.