U.S. tobacco control: Public health, political economy, or morality policy?

Abstract

Tobacco control policy usually has been framed in terms of public health and political economy, but it also has been called a morality issue. Through a systematic historical analysis, this paper examines dimensions of morality policy and evaluates tobacco control in the United States for its fit with those characteristics. Moral concerns have been a part of tobacco control policy at certain times, first in the early twentieth century, and, more recently, since the mid-1980s with the rise of "denormalization" of tobacco as a goal of some antitobacco organizations. Drawing from recent studies of other "morality" policy issues, it argues that tobacco control is a "blended" issue, one which can take on different dimensions depending on successful interest group framing. The adoption of Healthy Public Policy as a governmental goal has coincided with a movement toward a "secular morality" in the political culture, facilitating a broader appeal to the public. © 2008 by The Policy Studies Organization. All rights reserved.