Criteria for wind-turbine noise immissions

Abstract

Each of the two authors has developed single, 24-hour, constant wind turbine noise criteria; the criteria are constants because wind turbine noise is basically not adjustable. Hessler develops his criteria from his knowledge of how wind turbine noise is being regulated at the local, state, and national levels, from regulations in other countries, and from his extensive experience with numerous wind turbine projects. Schomer develops his recommended criteria on the basis of existing national and international standards, notably ISO 1996-1 and ANSI/ASA S12.9 parts 4 and 5. Ultimately, Hessler comes up with a single, 24-hour A-weighted average criterion of 40 dB, and Schomer comes up with a 24 hour, A-weighted average criterion of 39 dB. These two researchers have decidedly different backgrounds, different experience, and a slight difference in orientation towards the industry. Thus, it is remarkable that these two criteria, derived in such different ways result in nearly identical 24-hour A-weighted criteria levels. Although there is essential agreement in immissions criterion, there are variables debated herein for both modeling wind turbine emissions and certifying such emissions at far-off receptors that could result in a 10 dBA difference in the actual immissions level. © 2013 Acoustical Society of America.