Transcriptome analysis shows ambiguous phenotypes of murine primitive endoderm-related stem cell lines

Abstract

Primitive endoderm (PrE)-related cell lines (XEN, pXEN and nEnd cells) show key features of the PrE. By transcriptome analysis, we show: (a) Compared to embryonic stem cells, PrE-related cell lines are less in vivo like, although early nEnd cells are most similar to the PrE. (b) These cell lines show post-PrE features of parietal (XEN and pXEN cells) or visceral (nEnd cells) endoderm, likely driven by Tgf-β and Wnt/Activin signaling, respectively. (c) pXEN and nEnd cell lines additionally show pre-PrE features. Hence, neither pXEN nor nEnd cell cultures represent a distinct in vivo entity. Rather, their properties are compatible with mixed and hybrid phenotypes. Our findings indicate that pre-PrE, PrE and early post-PrE phenotypes result from different niches, which need to be better understood to derive cell lines that distinctly represent the early stages of the extraembryonic endoderm.