Asthma and asthma-like disorder, A 5-year follow-up study

Abstract

Consecutive adult patients (n=70) referred for investigation of suspected asthma were reinvestigated after 5 years with the same diagnostic procedures (airway symptom score, spirometry, methacholine test) as used at the initial investigation. The same diagnostic criteria for asthma, asthma-like disorder (current asthma-like symptoms but negative asthma tests) and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) were used at both visits. At the first visit 39/70 patients (56%) fulfilled the asthma criteria, 21/70 (27%) fulfilled the asthma-like criteria and 5/70 (7%) the COPD criteria. Due to lack of current symptoms 5/70 (7%) could not be classified. 5/70 patients (7%) were smokers, however, in the majority (72%) smoke was not tolerated as it induced asthma-like symptoms. At the investigation, 5 years later, 30/39 patients (76%) still fulfilled the asthma criteria and 12/21 patients (57%) still fulfilled the asthma-like criteria. At the 5-year investigation, 10% of patients in the asthma group now fulfilled the asthma-like criteria and 10% of patients in the asthma-like group fulfilled the asthma criteria. It is concluded that asthma as well an asthma-like syndrome may persist for 5 years or more. It is also concluded that the two disorders are closely related as patients in the asthma group over time could move into the diagnostic criteria of the asthma-like disorder and vice versa. © 2002 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.