Experimental and epidemic risks: Matters of science and judgement

Abstract

I wish to caution against undue weight being given to received wisdom and false assumptions of 'expertise', particularly in the context of new epidemics. I argue that, in some cases, reliance on received wisdom can lead to poor decision-making in public health terms, whether we are talking about Mad Cow Disease, the likelihood of a novel strain of influenza causing many fatalities, or the best way to reduce overdose deaths soon after release from prison. I shall also stress the importance of well-designed data-acquisition which is, or should be, the forte of statistician-scientists. © 2013 Academia Europæa.