Microcalcification detection using digital tomosynthesis, dual energy mammography and cone beam computed tomography: A comparative study

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to investigate and compare microcalcification detectability using Digital Tomosynthesis (DTS), Dual Energy Mammography (DEM) and Cone Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) with a flat-panel detector. A simulated 3D uncompressed breast approximating the medium sized breast, with 50% adipose and 50% glandular tissue was used. Microcalcifications were modeled as calcium carbonate spheres/ellipsoids with size in full range of 0.1 to 1mm. An amorphous-silicon CsI flatdetector, 2048 × 2048 mm2 at 0.1mm resolution was modeled. Images from the above phantom were simulated using three acquisition protocols for DTS, DEM and CBCT. For DTS, projections data were acquired for an acquisition arc from -200 to 200 with 20 sampling step, and the 3D reconstructed volume was obtained using a Multiple Projection Algorithm (MPA), with a 0.1 mm width between successive tomograms. In the DEM case, two synthetic projection images at 21 and 52 KeV respectively were simulated. A weighted subtraction of low and high - energy digital X-ray images was performed, allowing the removal of background morphology and enhancement of the obscured details. For the last method (CBCT), 181 projections acquired every 20 over a full circular scanning path were used for 3D breast volume reconstruction using the well-known FDK algorithm. The image quality of the reconstructed tomograms was visually assessed and quantified in terms of contrast to noise ratio (CNR), relative detail contrast (RC), as well as Artifacts Spread Function (ASF). The results show that microcalcifications with diameter equal or greater than 0.1mm can be detected, with the CBCT and DTS techniques. Superior quality is demonstrated by CBCT technique in comparison with DTS and DE by means of better microcalcification detection. © 2009 Springer Berlin Heidelberg.