Preliminary comparative assessment of various spectral indices for built-up land derived from Landsat-8 OLI and Sentinel-2A MSI imageries

Abstract

Urbanization in China has been rapid over the past three decades causing substantial replacement of the natural landscape by built-up land. In this paper, we present a comparison of Sentinel-2A MSI (S2A) and Landsat-8 OLI (L8) data in the retrieval of five built-up indices, namely Urban Index (UI), Normalized Difference Built-up Index (NDBI), Index-based Built-up Index (IBI) and two visible based indices, i.e. VgNIR-BI and VrNIR-BI. All the built-up indices maps water-masked were classified into built-up and non-built-up land using Otsu’s method. Simultaneously, the support vector machine (SVM) algorithm was employed to classify the two imageries into three respective classes. The accuracy assessment results show that all built-up indices had higher Overall Accuracy for S2A (up to 98.14% for VrNIR-BI) and L8 (up to 98.42% for VrNIR-BI) imageries compared to SVM. The percentage differences demonstrate that L8 estimates higher built-up area compared to S2A between 1.48% and 8.45% via the built-up indices and 13.40% compared to the SVM. Cross-checking with the Statistical Yearbook, S2A is superior to L8 in built-up land mapping capability, especially utilizing built-up indices. The difference caused by spatial resolution and spectral response functions should be taken into consideration in synergistic scientific application.