Is this the vReal Life? Manipulating Visual Fidelity of Immersive Environments for Medical Task Simulation

Abstract

Recent developments and research advances contribute to an ever-increasing trend towards quality levels close to what we experience in reality. In this work, we investigate how different degrees of these quality characteristics affect user performance, qualia of user experience (UX), and sense of presence in an example medical task. To this end, a two-way within-subjects design user study was conducted, in which three different levels of visual fidelity were compared. In addition, two different interaction modalities were considered: (1) the use of conventional VR controllers and (2) natural hand interaction using 3D-printed, spatially-registered replicas of medical devices, to interact with their virtual representations. Consistent results indicate that higher degrees of visual fidelity evoke a higher sense of presence and UX. However, user performance was less affected. Moreover, no differences were detected between both interaction modalities for the examined task. Future work should investigate the discovered interaction effects between quality levels and interaction modalities in more detail and examine whether these results can be reproduced in tasks that require more precision. This work provides insights into the implications to consider when studying interactions in VR and paves the way for investigations into early phases of medical product development and workflow analysis.