The efficiency of magnetic-activated cell sorting and fluorescence- activated cell sorting in the decontamination of testicular cell suspensions in cancer patients

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Before clinical application, the feasibility and safety of autologous testicular stem cell transplantation should be explored. Apart from limitations in their numbers, spermatogonial stem cells may also be contaminated by malignant cells. Therefore, both enrichment and decontamination before transplantation may be necessary. This study aimed at evaluating the decontaminating potential of magnetic-activated cell sorting (MACS) and/or fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) for both murine and human testicular cell suspensions. In the mouse, the effectiveness of the transplantation technique after cell sorting was also assessed. METHODS: Murine testicular cells were contaminated with 5% EL4 cells. Fresh and frozen-thawed suspensions were sorted using MACS (CD49f+) and FACS (CD49f+, H-2Kb -) and evaluated by FACS, cell culture and transplantation into W/Wv mice. Human testicular cells were contaminated with 5 or 0.05% CCRF-SB (SB) cells. Frozen-thawed suspensions were sorted using FACS (HLA class I -) and evaluated by FACS, cell culture and PCR for the B-cell receptor. RESULTS: In the mouse, the sorted fractions contained 0.39% H-2K b-positive and 76.55% CD49f-positive cells. After transplantation, 1 in 20 recipient mice developed a malignancy. In the human experiments, an average of 0.58% SB cells was detected after sorting. In only 1 of 11 samples, there were no SB cells observed. CONCLUSION: MACS and/or FACS are insufficient for completely depleting testicular tissue of malignant cells. Although more research on alternative decontamination techniques is necessary, developing a reliable method to screen a priori testicular tissue for malignant cells may be equally important. © The Author 2006. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the European Society of Human Reproduction and Embryology. All rights reserved.