Retaining women in a prenatal care randomized controlled trial in Canada: Implications for program planning

  • Tough S
  • Siever J
  • Johnston D
  • 1


    Mendeley users who have this article in their library.
  • N/A


    Citations of this article.


Background: Challenges to retention in prenatal care seem to exist under both universal systems of care, as in Canada, and non-universal systems of care, as in the United States. However, among populations being served by a system of publicly funded health care, the barriers are less well understood and universal uptake of prenatal services has not been realized. Determining the characteristics of women who dropped out of a prenatal care randomized controlled trial can help identify those who may need alternate retention and service approaches. Methods: In this study, pregnant women were randomized to: a) current standard of care; b) 'a' plus nursing support; or c) 'b' plus a paraprofessional home visitor. 16% of 2,015 women did not complete all three telephone interviews (197 dropped out and 124 became unreachable). Responders were compared to non-responders on demographics, lifestyle, psychosocial factors, and life events using chi-squared tests. Logistic regression models were constructed using stepwise logistic regression to determine the probability of not completing the prenatal program. Results: Completion rates did not differ by intervention. In comparison to responders, non-responders were more likely to be younger, less educated, have lower incomes, smoke, have low social support, have a history of depression, and have separated or divorced parents (all p < 0.05). Unreachable women were more likely to be single, use drugs, report distress and adverse life events (all p < 0.05). Non-Caucasian women were more likely to drop out (p = 0.002). Logistic regression modeling indicated that independent key risk factors for dropping out were: less than high school education, separated or divorced parents, lower social support, and being non-Caucasian. Pregnant women who were single/separated/divorced, less than 25 years old, had less than high school education, earned less than $40,000 in annual household income, and/or smoked had greater odds of becoming unreachable at some point during pregnancy and not completing the study. Conclusion: Women at risk due to lifestyle and challenging circumstances were difficult to retain in a prenatal care study, regardless of the intervention. For women with complex health, lifestyle and social issues, lack of retention may reflect incongruence between their needs and the program. Trial registration: Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN64070727. 2007 Tough et al; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

Author-supplied keywords

  • *pregnancy
  • *prenatal care
  • Canada
  • academic achievement
  • adult
  • age distribution
  • article
  • clinical trial
  • controlled clinical trial
  • controlled study
  • demography
  • depression
  • distress syndrome
  • divorce
  • drug abuse
  • female
  • health care planning
  • health program
  • high school
  • human
  • income
  • life event
  • lifestyle
  • major clinical study
  • nursing care
  • parent
  • pregnant woman
  • psychological aspect
  • race difference
  • randomized controlled trial
  • risk factor
  • smoking
  • social aspect
  • social support
  • standard
  • statistical analysis
  • telephone

Get free article suggestions today

Mendeley saves you time finding and organizing research

Sign up here
Already have an account ?Sign in

Find this document

There are no full text links


  • S C Tough

  • J E Siever

  • D W Johnston

Cite this document

Choose a citation style from the tabs below

Save time finding and organizing research with Mendeley

Sign up for free