Finding captain swing: Protest, parish relations, and the state of the public mind in 1830

Abstract

From the 1950s to the 1970s, the study of English popular protest was dominated by the work of Eric Hobsbawm, George Rud, and Edward Thompson, and it is no exaggeration to suggest that their combined approach became the standard against which all subsequent work was judged. It was seminal, innovative and crucial to the emergence of a new history from below. But it was, to a degree, also formulaic: it relied on a trusted framework that historians have since struggled to deviate from. Through a detailed investigation of a set of disturbances in Berkshire, England during the so-called Swing riots, this essay seeks to demonstrate that a continued reliance on this model can be seen to have stifled a more nuanced understanding of particular moments of protest in the locality, and in doing so it places a much greater emphasis on local social and in particular, parochial relations than has previously been the case. In sum, within the context of late-Hanoverian popular protest, this essay is a plea for a new history from within to supplement the (now venerable) tradition of history from below. © 2009 Internationaal Instituut voor Sociale Geschiedenis.