Care is not a tally sheet: rethinking the field of gender divisions of domestic labour with care-centric conceptual narratives

Abstract

This article addresses two puzzles that are at the heart of the field of gender divisions of domestic labour. How is it that care concepts seldom appear in a field that is focused on unpaid care work? Why does the field focus on divisions rather than on relationships and relationalities? To address these puzzles, I interrogate some of the conceptual underpinnings in the field's dominant theories: social exchange and 'doing gender'. Through a weaving of Margaret Somers' historical sociology of concept formation and Nancy Fraser's historical mapping of capitalism, care and social reproduction, I aim to rethink and remake the field of gender divisions of domestic labour through care theories, especially feminist care ethics and care economies research. I argue that care concepts - which highlight relationalities, responsiveness and responsibilities - can radically re-orient how we approach the 'who' and 'what' questions of this field's long-standing central focus on 'who does what?'.