Lack of correlation between facial sexual dimorphism, fluctuating asymmetry and self-perceived attractiveness in men and women

Abstract

Human morphological sexual dimorphism and fluctuating asymmetry have been suggested to signal 'individual quality' and are therefore expected to covary as well as to correlate with surrogate fitness/quality measures like attractiveness and dominance. While some case studies indeed found support for these hypotheses, the overall evidence is not overwhelming. However, most previous research used a limited number of landmarks to quantify masculinity and asymmetry. We here present results based on high-density 3D scans covering the entire facial area. In spite of these more detailed measurements, no significant associations were detected. These results are in line with conclusions of recent meta-analyses and cast doubt on the role of masculinity and fluctuating asymmetry as signals of (genetic) quality.