Implications of contrasting patterns of genetic variability in two vespertilionid bats from the Indonesian archipelago

Abstract

Wallacean island populations of two Vespertilioninae bats, Myotis muricola and Scotophilus kuhlii, which have similar geographical ranges, showed marked contrast in the amount and pattern of genetic variation. Within islands, genetic variation was on average much higher in M. muricola but declined from west to east, whereas all populations of S. kuhlii had uniformly low levels of genetic variation by mammalian standards. S. kuhlii showed little genetic differentiation between islands and estimates of gene flow were substantial whereas island populations of M. muricola differed markedly and there was a strong isolation-by-distance effect associated with the extent of the sea crossing between islands. Furthermore, the lower mean heterozygosity and small genetic distances between eastern island populations of M. muricola is evidence that there has been a bottleneck associated with the colonization of this area. The attenuation of genetic diversity to the east is also seen in some other mammalian species and may indicate limits to dispersal and have implications for species management. The patterns of variability in S. kuhlii may be a consequence of its strong dispersal capacity and close association with human activity, which, together with other factors, suggest a panmictic population. © 2004 The Linnean Society of London.