Systematic assessment of quaternary ammonium compounds for the potential to elicit developmental and reproductive effects

Abstract

Introduction: Quaternary ammonium compounds (QUATs) are commonly found in cleaning products, disinfectants, hand sanitizers, and personal care products. They have been used for >50 years and are considered safe when used according to directions. Recent papers report reduced fertility and neural tube defects in rodents after low-level exposures. To determine if QUATs interfere with mammalian reproduction and development, we conducted a methodical assessment of all available data. Methods: A systematic literature search identified 789 potential articles. Review of titles and abstracts found eight relevant studies, including two dissertation chapters; to these, 10 unpublished, guideline-compliant developmental and reproductive toxicity (DART) studies of QUATs (alkyldimethylbenzylammonium chloride [ADBAC] and dialkyldimethylammonium chloride [DDAC]) were added. ToxRTool was utilized to evaluate all 18 studies for data quality. Results: Six studies were scored as “reliable without restriction”; four studies were considered “reliable with restriction” (mainly due to small rabbit group sizes). No test article-related, adverse DART endpoints were reported in these studies. ToxRTool scored the remaining eight studies as “not reliable.” The unreliable studies failed to fully describe methods and/or endpoints, did not quantify (and in some cases, did not verify) exposures, utilized non-standard test methods, reported endpoints incorrectly, and assessed endpoints at inappropriate times. Some (not all) unreliable studies reported adverse effects after 7.5 mg QUATs/kg/day (mice), but these results were inconsistent. The reliable studies tested exposures ≥100 mg/kg/day (rats) with no effects. Conclusions: The available weight of evidence indicates no adverse DART effects after QUATs exposures at anticipated concentrations and normal use.