Image-magic in a midsummer night's dream: Power and modernity from Weber to Shakespeare

Abstract

This article argues that the modern world is not only produced by, and is promoting, processes of rationalization and disenchantment, but is also the site of 'enchanting' influences that are genuinely 'charming' or 'magical'. Such modes of influencing rely increasingly on the power of images, and on theatre-like performances of words or discourses. The impact takes place under conditions that, following Victor Turner's work, could be called 'liminal', and which can be turned through 'imagemagic' into a state of 'permanent liminality'. A path-breaking analysis of such influences can be found in Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream, written at a highly liminal moment in European history, the end of the Renaissance and the unfolding of the Reformation. It is argued that the central problem of the play is the source of the power that motivates, from the inside, human beings. Shakespeare attributes this power to images through which human beings can be incited to act, in particular to fall in love, and assigns a decisive role in the manipulation of such images to the Trickster figure of folk-tales and myths. Such image-magic makes its victims believe that they gained enlightenment, maturing to reason, exactly when succumbing to its influence; while its lasting impact is the confusion of the senses, or the power to distinguish and discriminate. © 2007 SAGE Publications.