Assessing scaffold diversity of kinase inhibitors using alternative scaffold concepts and estimating the scaffold hopping potential for different kinases

Abstract

Publicly available kinase inhibitors provide a large source of information for structure-activity relationship analysis and kinase drug design. In this study, publicly available inhibitors of the human kinome were collected and analog series formed by kinase inhibitors systematically identified. Then, alternative scaffold concepts were applied to assess diversity and promiscuity of kinase inhibitors. Over the past two years, the number of publicly available kinase inhibitors with high-confidence activity data more than doubled, but coverage of the human kinome only slightly increased. Approximately 70% of current kinase inhibitors belonged to analog series. However, the detectable degree of promiscuity among these kinase inhibitors remained low. Approximately 76% of all inhibitors were only annotated with a single kinase, compared to ~70% two years ago. For many kinases, the assessment of scaffold diversity among their inhibitors and the distribution of differently defined scaffolds over analog series made it possible to assess scaffold hopping potential. Our analysis revealed that the consideration of conventional compound-based scaffolds most likely leads to an overestimation of scaffold hopping frequency, at least for compounds forming analog series.