Optimal cutoff score for patient-reported outcome measures after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction using load–displacement curve analysis

Abstract

To assess psychological components after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury, we developed a new patient-reported outcome measure, the Japanese anterior cruciate ligament injury questionnaire 25 (JACL-25), and demonstrated that the JACL-25 is valid, reliable, and sufficiently responsive to evaluate psychological factors that are associated with outcomes in individuals with ACL injuries. The purpose of this study was to identify the optimum cutoff score for the JACL-25 that indicates successful clinical outcomes, combining with the graphical data obtained using the KT-2000. We studied 30 patients who underwent primary ACL reconstruction with a patella tendon or hamstring tendon autograft. On the same day of the JACL-25 evaluation, anterior knee laxity tests were performed using the KT-2000 arthrometer. ACL stiffness was calculated on the graphs of the hysteresis, which can be used to measure side-to-side differences in anterior translation. Akaike’s information criterion (AIC) was used to determine the most appropriate cutoff level for the JACL-25 score for the stiffness reduction ratio and anterior–posterior (AP) translation. The average JACL-25 score was 23.8 (standard deviation (SD) 18.4). The average side-to-side displacement difference in AP translation was 2.4 (SD 4.2) mm. The average stiffness reduction ratio was 24.4% (SD 31.8). The smallest AIC values for the cutoff level for the JACL-25 score, the stiffness reduction ratio, and side-to-side differences of the anterior translation were 9, 27%, and 1.1 mm, respectively. We determined the optimal cutoff score for the JACL-25 that identifies successful clinical outcomes.