Expanding two-way texting for post-operative follow-up: A cost analysis of the implementation and scale-up in routine voluntary medical male circumcision settings in South Africa

Abstract

Up to 98% of adult voluntary medical male circumcision (VMMC) clients heal without adverse events (AEs) in South Africa and in the sub-Saharan Africa region. Yet, all clients in South Africa are required to attend in-person reviews, creating added effort for providers and clients. A randomized controlled trial (RCT) using our fee-free, open-source, two-way texting (2wT) approach showed that males could independently monitor their healing with nurse-led telehealth support. 2wT was more cost-effective than routine visits for quality post-operative monitoring. The objectives of this study were:1) assess the additive cost of 2wT vs. standard of care (SoC) during a stepped wedge design (SWD) expansion trial; 2) determine the cost of augmenting 2wT implementation with dedicated personnel during peak VMMC periods; and 3) estimate the cost savings of 2wT from the payer perspective if scaled in routine settings. Data were collected from routine financial reports and complemented by previous RCT time-motion estimates. We conducted activity-based costing of SWD and peak season periods. Sensitivity analysis to estimates 2wT costs at scale. Data included 6,842 males; 2,586 (38%) opted for 2wT. 2wT participants attended an average of zero in-person visits; SoC males had an average of 2 in-person visits. Under 2wT, quality care improved: AE ascertainment increased while loss to follow-up decreased. Given a VMMC population of 10,000 adults, scenario analysis suggests that: 1) 2wT becomes cost neutral with 45% 2wT enrollment; 2) 2wT saves $0.29/client with 60% 2wT enrollment; and 3) 2wT saves $0.46/client with 80% 2wT enrollment. When scaled, 2wT appears to significantly reduce healthcare system costs while improving the quality of postoperative care without additional client costs. Further scale-up of 2wT for eligible males across VMMC and other post-operative contexts in South Africa would likely increase cost savings while dramatically reducing the burden of in-person visits on patients and clinics.