How enrichment, ecosystem size, and their effects on species richness co-determine the stability of microcosm communities

Abstract

Nutrient enrichment, ecosystem size, and richness each may directly affect the stability of both populations and communities. Alternatively, nutrient enrichment and ecosystem size each may directly affect richness, which in turn may affect stability. No previous studies, however, have tested empirically how these three factors interact and co-determine stability. We manipulated nutrient input and ecosystem size in replicate microcosms containing a diverse bacterial flora, and a range of green algae and heterotrophic protozoa, and used these manipulations and the resulting variation in species richness to measure their combined effects on temporal stability of both populations and communities. Results showed that nutrient enrichment and ecosystem size controlled protist richness, and their effects on stability could be mediated by richness. In addition, both community-level and population-level stability increased with protist richness. Furthermore, mean species evenness and mean species richness was negatively related. Effects of statistical averaging, overyielding, and component population stability were identified as possible mechanisms involved explaini ng the stabilizing effects of richness on community stability. Their relative strength in influencing stability, however, is likely to change as mean evenness decreased with increasing richness. This decrease in evenness would tend to weaken the strength of the statistic averaging effect, but increase the strength of the other two mechanisms due to relatively lower population variability (component population stability) and higher mean biovolumes of dominant protists (overyielding). © 2009 The Authors. Journal compilation © 2010 Oikos.