Clinical behavior of complicated right-sided and left-sided diverticulosis

Abstract

PURPOSE: The aim of the study was to characterize the clinical entity of multiple right-sided (RS) diverticular disease, which is uniquely common in Asians. METHODS: Patients hospitalized with proven diverticular disease from June 1989 to January 1996 were reviewed. Data were retrieved from a prospectively collected computerized database. RESULTS: One hundred eighty consecutive patients were admitted to the Department of Colorectal Surgery, Singapore General Hospital, with multiple diverticular disease. Average age was 65.1 (standard error of the mean, 13.9) years. There were 96 men and 84 women. Women presented, on average, 8.4 years later than men (P < 0.005). Eighty-five patients (47 percent) had massive rectal bleeding, 65 (36 percent) had diverticulitis, 21 (12 percent) had obstructive symptoms, and 9 (15 percent) had enteric fistulas. The diverticula were RS in 76 patients (42 percent), left-sided (LS) in 62 patients (34 percent), and on both sides in 42 patients (24 percent). RS diverticulosis tended to present with massive rectal bleeding (42/76; 55 percent) more often than LS disease (14/62; 23 percent; P < 0.005). Surgery for bleeding was also required more often for RS (17/42; 41 percent) than for LS disease (1/14; 7 percent; P < 0.05); however, diverticulitis was more common on the left (RS, 25/76, 33 percent; LS, 32/62, 52 percent; P < 0.05). Seventy-eight patients (43 percent) required surgery for these complications of diverticular disease. At a mean follow-up of 15.2 (standard error of the mean, 2) months, mortality was 2 in 78 patients who underwent surgery (3 percent), and morbidity was 15 percent. CONCLUSIONS: In comparison with LS, RS diverticular disease tended to present more often with massive bleeding than with diverticulitis and fistulation. This bleeding was often more severe and required surgical intervention.