Comparison of ganciclovir- and immune globulin-containing regimens in preventing cytomegalovirus infection in patients with renal transplants

Abstract

The effectiveness and costs of ganciclovir compared with intravenous immune globulin (IVIG) in the prevention of cytomegalovirus (CMV) disease were studied. A retrospective analysis was conducted of renal transplant patients treated with ganciclovir during the initial hospital stay followed by three months of acyclovir therapy and a historical control group that received IVIG at one, two, four, six, and eight weeks posttransplant and acyclovir at two weeks post-transplant and continued for three months. The average drug cost for each regimen and the average direct cost of treating CMV disease in each group were calculated. The overall frequency of CMV disease was 14% in the IVIG group (n=42) and 3% in the ganciclovir group (n=30). CMV disease occurred less frequently in all ganciclovir-treated subgroups, but the difference was significant only in the group in which the recipient was CMV seronegative and the donor CMV seropositive. No ganciclovir-related adverse events were noted. Three IVIG-related infusion reactions were noted. Treatment with ganciclovir decreased rug costs by approximately $2,775 per patient or $83,250 for the study sample. The overall avoided cost in the ganciclovir group was $102,575 ($3,419 per patient). Ganciclovir followed by acyclovir was significantly more effective than IVIG followed by acyclovir in the prevention of CMV disease in CMV-seronegative patients who received renal transplant from CMV-seropositive donors; among all patients studied, ganciclovir did not differ from IVIG in preventing CMV infection but was considerably less expensive.