Follicular fluid and supernatant from cultured cumulus-granulosa cells improve in vitro maturation in patients with polycystic ovarian syndrome

Abstract

Objective: To study the effectiveness of a new in vitro maturation (IVM) approach based on heterologous follicular fluid (HFF) and supernatant of cumulus-granulosa cells (CGCs) mimicking the intact follicular microenvironment to rescue immature denuded oocytes (IDOs) of patients with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) whose IVM or IVF outcomes remain poor. Design: Randomized controlled trial. Setting: University-affiliated private center. Patient(s): One hundred fifty-nine IDOs were obtained from 47 patients with PCOS. First, a simple IVM system (S-IVM; 40 IDOs; control group) was compared with different protocols based on the addition of autologous follicular fluid (AFF-IVM; 44 IDOs), HFF (HFF-IVM; 42 IDO), or HFF with CGC isolated from seven women without PCOS and presenting 100% in vivo oocyte maturation (HFF/CGC-IVM; 33 IDOs). Intervention(s): None. Main Outcome Measure(s): IVM outcomes were compared among the four groups (S-IVM, AFF-IVM, HFF-IVM, HFF/CGC-IVM); then the vitro and in vivo maturation results (from controlled ovarian stimulation of PCOS patients) were compared for each group. Result(s): The HFF/CGC-IVM method gave the best yield of developed blastocysts per IDO compared with S-IVM, AFF-IVM, and HFF-IVM (27% vs. 2%, 2%, and 12%, respectively). The IVM rate with the HFF/CGC-IVM method was even higher than that compared with the in vivo maturation rate (79% vs. 42%), with significant improvement in the cleavage rate (71% vs. 61%). Conclusion(s): This adapted IVM system could be used to reach an acceptable result in meiotic competence and competent metaphase II oocytes capable of developing into intact embryos after fertilization and before transfer.