Multiobjective tree-based reinforcement learning for estimating tolerant dynamic treatment regimes

Abstract

A dynamic treatment regime (DTR) is a sequence of treatment decision rules that dictate individualized treatments based on evolving treatment and covariate history. It provides a vehicle for optimizing a clinical decision support system and fits well into the broader paradigm of personalized medicine. However, many real-world problems involve multiple competing priorities, and decision rules differ when trade-offs are present. Correspondingly, there may be more than one feasible decision that leads to empirically sufficient optimization. In this paper, we propose a concept of “tolerant regime,” which provides a set of individualized feasible decision rules under a prespecified tolerance rate. A multiobjective tree-based reinforcement learning (MOT-RL) method is developed to directly estimate the tolerant DTR (tDTR) that optimizes multiple objectives in a multistage multitreatment setting. At each stage, MOT-RL constructs an unsupervised decision tree by modeling the counterfactual mean outcome of each objective via semiparametric regression and maximizing a purity measure constructed by the scalarized augmented inverse probability weighted estimators (SAIPWE). The algorithm is implemented in a backward inductive manner through multiple decision stages, and it estimates the optimal DTR and tDTR depending on the decision-maker’s preferences. Multiobjective tree-based reinforcement learning is robust, efficient, easy-to-interpret, and flexible to different settings. We apply MOT-RL to evaluate 2-stage chemotherapy regimes that reduce disease burden and prolong survival for advanced prostate cancer patients using a dataset collected at MD Anderson Cancer Center.