Relative importance of trophic group concentrations during anaerobic degradation of volatile fatty acids

Abstract

Although obligate syntrophic reactions cannot proceed without hydrogenotrophs, it has been unclear from the literature whether potential improvements are achievable with higher concentrations of hydrogenotrophs. In this study, the relative importance of formate-/H2-utilizing and acetate- utilizing trophic groups in the anaerobic degradation of butyrate and propionate was assessed by adding various proportions of these enriched cultures to a mixed anaerobic seed inoculum. The improvement resulting from the additional acetate-utilizing cultures was much greater than with formate/H2 utilizers. Furthermore, formate/H2 utilizers did not improve propionate utilization significantly, suggesting the importance of optimum utilization of hydrogenotrophic capacity. During most of the volatile fatty acid (VFA) degradation period, the system responded with characteristic hydrogen levels to maintain the Gibbs free energy of oxidation approximately constant for both butyrate (-6 kJ) and propionate (-14 kJ). These free-energy values were independent of methanogenic activity, as well as the volume of the seed inoculum and the VFA concentrations present. By comparing the experimental results with kinetic and mass transfer models, it was postulated that the diffusional transfer of reducing equivalents was the major limiting factor for efficient VFA degradation. Therefore, for optimum utilization of the hydrogenotrophs, low acetate concentrations are vital to enable the system to respond with higher formate/H2 levels, thus leading to improved transfer of reducing equivalents. Due to the small number of propionate utilizers (and hence their limited surface area) and low bulk liquid concentrations, the additional formate/H2 utilizers were of minimal use for improving the degradation rate further. The butyrate degradation rates strongly correlated with the cumulative activity of hydrogenotrophs and acetotrophs over the experimental range studied, indicating the need to model obligate syntrophic reactions as a dependent function of methanogenic activity.