El derecho administrativo ante la jurisprudencia de la Corte Suprema, II: Líneas y vacilaciones durante 2019

Abstract

This text is the continuation of a previous work on the lines and vacillations of the jurisprudence of the Supreme Court in twenty subjects of administrative law during the 2008-2018 decade; which is now updated for the 2019 calendar year. It synthesizes and graphs the result of an investigation of a volume of 333 Supreme Court judgments of the year 2019 on twenty relevant issues of the praxis of administrative law. Its format is synthetic. Regarding each issue, it is indicated: the facts that originated the conflict; the ratio iuris decidendi; graphics that evidences the linear or zigzagging behavior of both the Chamber as of its ministers and member attorneys; an analysis of such behavior; and, an exhaustive count of rulings. The result is different from that of the first study: although some vacillations of the Supreme Court persist, now during 2019 there is a new trend aimed at offering precedents. There is a slight increase in topics with uniform jurisprudence. However, some erratic conduct of some of its member ministers and member attorneys is maintained.