Forest landscape heterogeneity increases shrub diversity at the expense of tree seedling diversity in temperate mixedwood forests

Abstract

Partial disturbances enhance spatial heterogeneity through the diversification of forest structure, which contributes to niche partitioning and consequently to species diversity. However, this heterogeneity-diversity relationship may differ between groups of species, and is potentially modified by biotic interactions at the community level. We propose that shrub diversity will be greater in heterogeneous landscapes, while tree diversity will be lower in those same landscapes, due to the biotic interactions of shrub competition. We conducted field sampling in the balsam fir/yellow birch bioclimatic domain in western Quebec, a forested ecosystem disturbed by natural and anthropogenic partial disturbances. We selected 12 forested landscapes (1 km2), four in each of three classes of landscape heterogeneity (heterogeneous, moderately heterogeneous, homogenous). Shrub and tree species regeneration abundance was measured in three different size classes of canopy gaps and the forest understory. Gap proportions were assessed in each landscape using aerial LiDAR data. Tree and shrub alpha-diversity significantly responded to landscape heterogeneity, shrubs being more diverse while tree seedlings were less diverse in heterogeneous landscapes. Heterogeneous landscapes showed highest species accumulation rates for shrubs in medium-sized gaps. For tree seedlings, species accumulation rates were highest in heterogeneous landscapes in the forest understory. Our study thus supports the heterogeneity-diversity relationship with shrubs having higher alpha and beta diversity in heterogeneous landscapes whereas local-scale tree diversity was higher in homogenous landscapes.