Beyond the tax haven: a graph analysis of business attraction in Swiss municipalities

Abstract

Switzerland’s decentralized fiscal structure has long been anecdotally credited with creating intense tax competition among its municipalities, famously attracting businesses to cantons like Zug. This research proposes a data-driven analysis of the factors that influence the business landscape in 226 Swiss municipalities from 2011 to 2022. By leveraging a rich collection of spatio-temporal open datasets, we build a predictive model of business creation and use explainable AI techniques to uncover the key socioeconomic drivers of municipal attractiveness. Our core methodology uses machine learning models, particularly graph neural networks (GNNs), to learn and capture the complex interdependencies between municipalities. Here, a GNN using attention mechanisms performs the best with a median R2=0.832 when using business sector demographics, population, municipal expenditure, and tax rate feature sets. Combining the trained models with explainable AI, we find that the most important features are coming from the business statistics datasets, rather than the tax data. However, a more granular analysis of municipalities grouped by primary language shows a different set of important features, highlighting the importance of a contextual, localized approach rather than a one-size-fits-all analysis. This study will provide a nuanced understanding of the interaction between tax policies, demographics, infrastructure, and other factors in shaping Switzerland’s economic geography.