Comparison between two non-contact techniques for art digitalization

Abstract

Many measurements techniques have been proposed for the "digitalization of objects": structured light 3D scanner, laser scanner, high resolution camera, depth cam, thermal-cam, ... Since the adoption of the European Agenda for Culture in 2007, heritage has been a priority for the Council's work plans for culture, and cooperation at European level has advanced through the Open Method of Coordination. Political interest at EU level has steadily grown cultural and heritage stakeholders recently highlighted in the Declaration on a New Narrative for Europe: "Europe as a political body needs to recognize the value of Cultural Heritage". Photomodelling is an innovative and extremely economical technique related to the conservation of Cultural Heritage, which leads to the creation of three-dimensional models starting from simple photographs. The aim of the research is to understand the full potential offered by this new technique and dedicated software, analysing the reliability of each instrument, with particular attention to freeware ones. An analytical comparison between photomodelling and structured light 3D scanner guarantees a first measure of the reliability of instruments, tested in the survey of several Umbrian heritage artefacts. The comparison between tests and reference models is explained using different algorithms and criteria, spatial, volumetric and superficial.