Population Abundance and Diversion Losses in a Threatened Estuarine Pelagic Fish

Abstract

Variation in freshwater flow into estuaries can profoundly alter abundance of estuarine organisms through a variety of mechanisms. In the San Francisco Estuary, California, an annual abundance index of juvenile longfin smelt Spirinchus thaleichthys has varied by ~ 100-fold over the range of flow, and over the last five decades the index has declined by over 100-fold. The unknown mechanisms for variation with flow may include removal of larvae by freshwater diversions during low-flow periods. Using data from larval trawl surveys during January–March 2009–2020, we estimated larval population size, its response to freshwater flow, and losses of larvae to freshwater diversions. Population size was estimated by a Bayesian hierarchical model linking a process model, with salinity and water clarity as covariates, to an observation model representing catch by a negative binomial distribution. Population size averaged across surveys within years—an index of the number of larvae produced—decreased over the study period from ~ 109 to 108 larvae. Population size was unrelated to freshwater flow in the year of hatching but positively related to the subsequent juvenile abundance index. Thus, the mechanisms underlying the strong variability in the annual abundance index of longfin smelt with freshwater flow are constrained to occur after March. Estimated proportional losses to water diversions accumulated over the period of vulnerability averaged 1.5% of the population, too low to measurably influence population dynamics.