A survey of the effectiveness of the assessment of the welfare of the child in UK in-vitro fertilization units

Abstract

Seventy-one clinics in the UK offering in-vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment were surveyed for their protocols on the assessment of the welfare of the children produced. A total of 44 (62%) responded. Of these, five (12%) did not have operational protocols, seven (16%) declined to provide their protocols, and 32 (73%) provided information used in the survey. The information was in the form of a protocol for only 16 (50%) of these clinics. The remaining clinics submitted as their 'protocols' letters to general practitioners, patient information, patient questionnaires and/or a copy of their policy on the assessment of child welfare. From the submitted material, it was possible to determine that 94% of clinics seek information on aspects of child welfare assessment, 78% have a procedure for making further enquiries where there is any cause for concern, 44% include counselling opportunities explicitly in protocols, 30-38% of clinics see a full medical and social history from each prospective parent as part of the child welfare assessment, 16% include explicit consideration of the impact of multiple births on the welfare of the child, and 3% include consideration of the issue of disclosure of the mode of conception of the child on its welfare. Most clinics did not have clearly defined procedures on how to reach a decision on whether or not to treat. Eight clinics (25%) made explicit in their protocols any exclusion criteria. It is concluded that clinics are not currently producing completely effective protocols. Two possible reasons for this are considered: lack of technical knowledge about what constitutes an effective protocol, and lack of clear policy development and propagation underlying protocols within clinics. Possible approaches to improving the situation are considered.