A comparative clinical study on five types of compression therapy in patients with venous leg ulcers

Abstract

The aim of this study was to compare five types of compression therapy in venous leg ulcers (intermittent pneumatic vs. stockings vs. multi layer vs. two layer short stretch bandages vs. Unna boots). Primary study endpoints were analysis of changes of the total ulcer surface area, volume and linear dimensions inside observed groups. The secondary end points were comparisons between all groups the number of completely healed wounds (ulcer healing rates), Gilman index and percentage change of ulcer surface area. In total, 147 patients with unilateral venous leg ulcers were included to this study. Participants were randomly allocated to the groups: A, B, C, D and E. After two months the healing rate was the highest in group A (intermittent pneumatic compression)-57.14%, 16/28 patients, B (ulcer stocking system)-56.66%, 17/30 patients and C (multi layer short stretch bandage)-58.62%, 17/29 patients. Significantly much worse rate found in group D (two layer short stretch bandages)-only 16.66%, 5/30 patients and E (Unna boots)-20%, 6/30 patients. The analysis of changes of the percentage of Gilman index and wound total surface area confirmed that intermittent pneumatic compression, stockings and multi layer bandages are the most efficient. The two layer short-stretch bandages and Unna boots appeared again much less effective. © Ivyspring International Publisher.