Altruism and the Indispensability of Motives

Abstract

In this paper we examine Fehr's notions of "altruism", "strong reciprocity"and "altruistic punishment"and query his ascription of altruism. We suggest that, pace Fehr, altruism cannot be defined behaviourally because the definition of altruism must refer to the motives of actors. We also advert to certain inconsistencies in Fehr's usage of his terms and we question his explanation of altruism in terms of 'social preferences'.