Lettuce Performance in a Tri-Trophic System Incorporating Crops, Fish and Insects Confirms the Feasibility of Circularity in Agricultural Production

Abstract

A circular tri-trophic system integrating aquaponics, i.e., combined cultivation of crops and fish, with insect rearing is presented for lettuce cultivation. The nutrition cycle among crops, insects and fish turns waste into resource, thereby increasing the sustainability of this food production system. A comprehensive evaluation of the system’s efficiency was performed, including the growth, functional and resource use efficiency traits of lettuce, the dynamics of which were followed in a pilot-scale aquaponics greenhouse, under three treatments: conventional hydroponics (HP) as the control, coupled aquaponics (CAP) with crops irrigated with fish-derived water, and decoupled aquaponics (DCAP), where fish-derived water was amended with fertilizers to reach the HP target. The main findings indicate comparable physiological performance between DCAP and HP, despite the slightly lower yield observed in the former. The CAP treatment exhibited a significant decrease in biomass accumulation and functional impairments, which were attributed to reduced nutrient levels in lettuce leaves. The DCAP treatment exhibited a 180% increase in fertilizer use efficiency compared to the HP treatment. We conclude that the tri-trophic cropping system with the implementation of DCAP variant is an effective system that enables the combined production of crops and fish, the latter being fed with sustainably derived insect protein. The tri-trophic system improves the environmental impact and sustainability of lettuce production, while making circularity feasible.