Digital Maturity Assessment Tools for the Construction Industry: A PRISMA-ScR Scoping Review

Abstract

This paper presents a PRISMA-ScR scoping review of 20 digital maturity assessment tools in the architecture, engineering, and construction (AEC) sector and wider business domains. The objective is to compare key features including assessment matrices, maturity dimensions, completion time, accessibility, and platform availability. The review follows predefined eligibility criteria and a structured screening process to identify and analyse tool frameworks in terms of scope, metrics, platform type, usability, and focus areas. Most tools primarily target the AEC sector, while some address broader organisational digital transformation. Common maturity areas include technology, organisation, data management, and processes. The analysis highlights limitations such as underemphasis on people, strategy, policy, skills development, standards, and financial resources, as well as the fragmented integration of maturity components. A combined bottom-up (scoring) and top-down (dimension structuring) approach is recommended for future tool development. The review provides insights for practitioners when selecting tools and proposes guidelines for creating more comprehensive and integrated maturity models.