Comparative Study on Blast Damage Features of Reinforced Concrete Slabs with Polyurethane Sacrificial Cladding Based on Different Numerical Simulation Methods

Abstract

The defense effects of sacrificial cladding have been extensively studied in the field of blast resistance. As a polymer material with a cellular structure, polyurethane also has the potential to act as sacrificial cladding due to its good mechanical properties. The purpose of this study is to compare and select a numerical simulation method that is suitable for exploring the blast damage mitigation effect of polyurethane sacrificial cladding on reinforced concrete slabs. To this end, three numerical models were developed using the Fully Coupled Eulerian–Lagrangian (CEL) method, the Arbitrary Lagrangian–Eulerian (ALE) coupling method, and the Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics and Finite Element Method (SPH–FEM) coupling method, respectively. These three numerical models were used to investigate the damage features of reinforced concrete slabs with polyurethane sacrificial cladding (PU–RCS) under contact explosions. A field test was also carried out to provide a comparison for numerical simulation results. Moreover, the advantages and disadvantages of the three simulation results and the applicability of the three coupled models were discussed. The results show that compared with the CEL model and the ALE coupling model, the SPH–FEM coupling model can better simulate the damage features of PU–RCS, such as the cracks on the bottom surface of the RC slab and the large deformation failure state of polyurethane sacrificial cladding, while the CEL model and the ALE coupling model can simulate the propagation process of shock waves and have a lower computational cost. In conclusion, the SPH–FEM coupling method is the most applicable method for exploring the blast damage features of PU–RCS in this study.