Ultra Low-Coverage Whole-Genome Sequencing as an Alternative to Genotyping Arrays in Genome-Wide Association Studies

Abstract

An array-based genotyping approach has been the standard practice for genome-wide association studies (GWASs); however, as sequencing costs plummet over the past years, ultra low-coverage whole-genome sequencing (ulcWGS <0.5× coverage) has emerged as a promising alternative that provides superior genomic coverage with substantial reduction of genotyping cost. To evaluate the potential utility of ulcWGS, we performed a whole-genome sequencing (WGS) of 72 European individuals to a target coverage of 0.4× and compared its performance with the widely used Infinium Global Screening Multi-Disease Array (GSA-MD). We showed that the number of variants captured by ulcWGS is comparable with imputed GSA-MD platform, particularly for low-frequency (95.5%) and common variants (99.9%), with high imputation R2 accuracy (mean 0.93 for SNPs and 0.86 for indels). Using deep-coverage 30× WGS as the “truth” genotypes, we found that ulcWGS has higher overall nonreference genotype concordance compared with imputed GSA-MD for both SNPs (0.90 vs. 0.88) and indels (0.86 vs. 0.83). In addition, ulcWGS proved to be as sensitive as the genotyping-based method in sex imputation and ancestry prediction producing similar principal component (PC) scores. Our findings provide important evidence that the cost efficient ulcWGS of <0.5× generates high genotype accuracy, outperforming the standard genotyping arrays, making it an attractive alternative to the array-based method in next-generation GWAS design.