Testing for cattle allergy: Modified diagnostic cutoff levels improve sensitivity in symptomatic claw trimmers

Abstract

Background: The diagnosis of cattle-related sensitization is complicated by the variability and complexity of cattle allergen extracts. Objective: To evaluate a modified diagnostic procedure leading to more accurate results especially in the early phase of sensitization. Methods: We tested 27 claw trimmers with and 65 without cattle-related symptoms using two commercially available cattle allergen extracts. We also used a self-prepared cattle allergen mix designed to represent the full spectrum of cattle allergens from a typical agricultural workplace. Results: More than 50% of symptomatic claw trimmers showed negative test results with commercial extracts and a sensitization cutoff point of 0.35 kU/l. In contrast, with the self-prepared cattle allergen mix, positive results were observed for almost all of them. Evaluating the results of the commercial test kits at different cutoff levels, we found an ideal cutoff point to improve the sensitivity at 0.2 kU/l. Conclusion: Additional tests with self-made cattle hair extracts can help to bridge the diagnostic gap seen in patients showing cattle-related symptoms, but negative results in commercially available tests. For early-stage sensitization screening, we propose to lower the cutoff level indicating sensitization to 0.2 kU/l. © 2010 The Author(s).