Scaphoid tubercle tenderness: A better indicator of scaphoid fractures?

Abstract

Tenderness in the anatomical snuff box (ASB) has long been accepted as an indicator of a possible scaphoid fracture. The longitudinal axis of the scaphoid lies in an anteroposterior plane, perpendicular to the remainder of the carpal bones, in the radially deviated wrist. The scaphoid tubercle can therefore be easily and accurately palpated on the palmar aspect of the radially deviated wrist. This study was devised to determine if tenderness over the scaphoid tubercle (ST) was superior to ASB tenderness in identifying definte fractures. Ove a 10-month period 246 patients were seen who were suspected of havind a scaphoid injury. Thirty (12%) were eventually proven to have definite fracture. Tenderness in the ASB had a sensitivity rate of 90% (95% confidence limits 80-100%) and specificity of 40% (33-47%) as an indicator of a definite fracture. ST tenderness had a sensitivity of 87% (75-99%) and specificity of 57% (50-64%). There is therefore no significant difference in the sensitivity between ASB and ST tenderness but ST tenderness is significantly more specific. However, the presence of either ASB or ST tenderness should be used in order to identify all fractures. Patients with neither ASB nor ST tenderness require symptomatic treatment only.