Non-Destructive Estimation of Deciduous Forest Metrics: Comparisons between UAV-LiDAR, UAV-DAP, and Terrestrial LiDAR Leaf-Off Point Clouds Using Two QSMs

Abstract

Timely acquisition of forest structure is crucial for understanding the dynamics of ecosystem functions. Despite the fact that the combination of different quantitative structure models (QSMs) and point cloud sources (ALS and DAP) has shown great potential to characterize tree structure, few studies have addressed their pros and cons in alpine temperate deciduous forests. In this study, different point clouds from UAV-mounted LiDAR and DAP under leaf-off conditions were first processed into individual tree point clouds, and then explicit 3D tree models of the forest were reconstructed using the TreeQSM and AdQSM methods. Structural metrics obtained from the two QSMs were evaluated based on terrestrial LiDAR (TLS)-based surveys. The results showed that ALS-based predictions of forest structure outperformed DAP-based predictions at both plot and tree levels. TreeQSM performed with comparable accuracy to AdQSM for estimating tree height, regardless of ALS (plot level: 0.93 vs. 0.94; tree level: 0.92 vs. 0.92) and DAP (plot level: 0.86 vs. 0.86; tree level: 0.89 vs. 0.90) point clouds. These results provide a robust and efficient workflow that takes advantage of UAV monitoring for estimating forest structural metrics and suggest the effectiveness of LiDAR in temperate deciduous forests.