Family history as a major prerequisite for microsatellite instability screening in colorectal cancer is a poor selection tool

Abstract

Background: Deficient mismatch repair (MMR) leading to microsatellite instability (MSI) in tumors is thought to be present in over 15% of colorectal cancer (CRC) cases. Testing CRC for MSI has traditionally been recommended following the fulfillment of clinical criteria. However, the performance of clinical criteria, especially the family history, as a selection tool for MSI screening in CRC is questionable. Methods: We retrospectively investigated the incidence of high degree MSI (MSI-H) tumors in an unselected population of CRC patients and compared its prevalence between individuals with and without family history of cancers within the spectrum of MSI-H tumors as defined in the revised Bethesda criteria. Results: The study population included 274 patients, 70 with positive and 204 without family history of MSI-H tumors with complete data including findings from MSI analysis. The overall incidence of MSI-H CRC was 18.98%. There was no statistically significant difference in the incidence of MSI-H CRC amongst both groups. The sensitivity and specificity of family history with regard to the presence of an MSI-H tumor in this collective was 36.5% and 77.5%, respectively. Conclusions: A relevant number of cases with high MSI-H CRC may be missed secondary to screening based on clinical criteria like family history alone. Thus, systematic screening independent of clinical characteristics, especially family history of cancer should be recommended in all cases with CRC.