Strategic Complexity and Behavioral Distortion: Retail Investing Under Large Language Model Augmentation

Abstract

This conceptual article introduces Perceived Cognitive Assistance (PCA)—a novel psychological construct capturing how interactive support from Large Language Models (LLMs) alters investors’ perception of their cognitive capacity to execute complex trading strategies. PCA formalizes a behavioral shift: LLM-empowered retail investors may transition from intuitive heuristics to institutional-grade strategies—sometimes without adequate comprehension. This empowerment–distortion duality forms the theoretical contribution’s core. To empirically validate this model, this article outlines a five-step research agenda including psychological diagnostics, trading behavior analysis, market efficiency tests, and a Behavioral Shift Index (BSI). One agenda component—a dual-agent simulation framework—enables causal benchmarking in post-LLM environments. This simulation includes two contributions: (1) the Virtual Trader, a cognitively degraded benchmark approximating bounded human reasoning, and (2) the Digital Persona, a psychologically emulated agent grounded in behaviorally plausible logic. These components offer methods for isolating LLM assistance’s cognitive uplift and evaluating behavioral implications under controlled conditions. This article contributes by specifying a testable link from established decision frameworks (Theory of Planned Behavior, Technology Acceptance Model, and Risk-as-Feelings) to two estimators: a moderated regression for individual decisions (Equation (1)) and a composite Behavioral Shift Index derived from trading logs (Equation (2)). We state directional, falsifiable predictions for the regression coefficients and for index dynamics, and we outline an identification and robustness plan—versioned, time-locked, and auditable—to be executed in the subsequent empirical phase. The result is a clear operational pathway from theory to measurement and testing, prior to empirical implementation. No empirical results are reported here; the contribution is the operational, falsifiable architecture and its implementation plan, to be executed in a separate preregistered study.